Alec Nevala-Lee

Thoughts on art, creativity, and the writing life.

The magical life of Henning Nelms

with 4 comments

“Specialization,” Robert Heinlein wrote, “is for insects,” and recently, I’ve become fascinated by the life of a man named Henning Nelms, aka Hake Talbot, who, as much as any author I know, embodies the idea that a writer needs to know a bit about everything. Nelms was born in Baltimore in 1900, and after obtaining an undergraduate degree from George Washington University, he studied law at the University of Georgia and got his MFA at Yale. He made his living primarily as a lawyer, but also worked in advertising and editing and was the head of the drama department at Middlebury College. In addition to his two mystery novels, one of which is a classic, he wrote plays and published several books on stagecraft and set design, but he’s perhaps best known today as a magician. Indeed, you’ll often find articles on Nelms that refer to him either as a magician or a mystery novelist, mentioning his other field of interest only in passing, when in fact he made an indelible impression in both.

I first got to know Nelms through his wonderful book Thinking With a Pencil, which I read when I was younger and recently bought again after realizing that I needed to own a copy. The title says it all: its 350 pages are packed with insight on basic sketching techniques, tracing, cartooning, figure drawing, perspective, lettering, the creation of diagrams and schematics, the presentation of data in charts and tables, and much more, all of it apparently picked up on the fly in a life of solving problems on the stage and in print. His book Magic and Showmanship takes a similar approach to conjuring: it covers the basics of sleight of hand, the construction of props and effects, and the preparation of stage patter and narrative, all of which are treated as parts of a seamless whole. In short, it envisions magic as a special case of storytelling, and much of its advice applies equally well to the writer as to the magician. For instance:

When you try to achieve a rising curve [of interest], keeping the beginning low is as important as making the ending high. If you start with a strong number, the next few effects will let the curve sag—and you may never be able to make it rise again. Dramatists know this; nearly every play opens with a scene that is deliberately dull. Its only function is to secure attention. If your first effect leaves your audience breathless, you will never be able to top it…Each peak and each valley should be higher than the one before it.

Given all this, it was perhaps inevitable that Nelms would also try his hand at mystery fiction, which was so suited for his particular bag of tricks. He wrote only two novels, under the pseudonym Hake Talbot, but his more famous book, Rim of the Pit, has been voted the second-greatest locked room mystery of all time (behind only John Dickson Carr’s The Three Coffins, which can be expected to take the top position in any poll). I recently read Rim of the Pit, and while it has some of the weaknesses of the locked room genre in general—everything, including character, is subordinated to the puzzle, and the writing is fair at best—it’s still a fine showcase for Nelms’s talents. A group of potential victims and suspects are gathered in a cabin in the woods for a story that plays like an encyclopedia of impossible crimes: ghosts appear and disappear; a dead body is found in pristine snow, without any footprints nearby; and, of course, a killer vanishes from a room in which there can be no possible escape.

The answer, as always, is never quite as satisfying as the mystery itself, but Nelms plays fair, misleads us beautifully, and comes up with a number of really ingenious solutions. (His approach to the problem of the body surrounded by untouched snow is particularly inventive.) And the book reflects Nelms’s remarkable personality: it’s full of magical lore, testifying to his wide reading in the literature of the supernatural, and it even gives him a chance to show off his skills as a draftsman—the map on the back cover of the original edition was drawn by the author himself. These days, Nelms, who died in 1986, isn’t well known outside the circles of magicians and mystery enthusiasts, but he embodies the kind of writer I tend to admire most: the jack of all trades, equal to any challenge, with a deep well of experience derived from surprising places. And if specialization is for insects, then Nelms is a model for all of us who hope to be something more.

Written by nevalalee

June 22, 2012 at 9:57 am

4 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Thanks for posting a tribute to Henning Nelms. My name is Ken Jennings — no I’m not the Ken Jennings of Jeopardy fame . . . BUT I am his father. Someone recently asked me to list the ten most influential non-fiction books in my life. One of the first to go on the list was Henning Nelms’ “Thinking with a Pencil.” I’m also a Heinlein fan and agree that “specialization is for insects.” It may not be possible to become a true”Renaissance Man” in our modern complex world but I gave it my best shot! And my wife (a librarian) and I tried to pass along this philosophy to our children. So, in a somewhat circuitous sense, Henning Nelms contributed significantly to my son’s love of all knowledge which, in turn, prepared him for his feat on Jeopardy! — and greater feats to come. He is writing an extensive series of intermediate-grade non-fiction books for Simon and Schuster. Cheers!

    Ken Jennings

    August 16, 2013 at 5:42 pm

  2. Thanks for visiting! Your son’s first AMA on Reddit is one of my favorite things of all time.

    And it’s always nice to meet another Henning Nelms fan. Have you checked out his other books? Magic and Showmanship is particularly wonderful.

    nevalalee

    August 16, 2013 at 9:22 pm

  3. Henning Nelms’ book on magic is highlighted in the forthcoming Episode 60 of my podcast – “Magic From Wherever I’m At.” (titled facetiously for a writer) comes out on the 30th of June 2019 – I could not, as of yet, find a picture of him. Elusive.

    Dartagnan Magic

    June 22, 2019 at 5:40 pm

  4. I’ve got five or six of his books, and you’re right—no author photo! Thanks for letting me know about your podcast—I’ll be sure to check it out.

    nevalalee

    June 23, 2019 at 9:00 am


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: