Alec Nevala-Lee

Thoughts on art, creativity, and the writing life.

Confessions of an advertising fan

with one comment

Farmer ad by Dodge Ram

Note: Every Friday, The A.V. Club, my favorite pop cultural site on the Internet, throws out a question to its staff members for discussion, and I’ve decided that I want to join in on the fun. This week’s question: “What’s your all-time favorite Super Bowl commercial?”

Of all the works on creativity I’ve internalized over the years, one of the most singular and least expected is Ogilvy on Advertising. David Ogilivy is best remembered today as the founder of one of the agencies that provided much of the inspiration for Mad Men, but he was perhaps the greatest genius the field ever produced, and his book is a masterpiece: in design, style, and feel, it’s the equal of any of his unforgettable ads, and I can’t pick it up without browsing through it cover to cover. A lot of this is due to the seductiveness of the ads themselves, many of which, like that for the Rolls-Royce and its famous electric clock, make better reading than most of the magazines in which they originally appeared. Ogilvy’s influence, while enormous, has become harder to discern in contemporary advertising, which is a shame. If more ad agencies—or their clients—shared his emphasis on clear, readable, fascinating copy, rather than just providing a picture of the product and a link to a web page, we’d all be better off. (The look of this blog, with its stark black type on a white background, is directly influenced by Ogilvy’s favorite layout, especially his belief that text on any kind of colored backdrop was unreadable.)

And I still think that it’s worthwhile for creative artists to study advertising, not so much because we’re trying to push anything on the reader, but because the best ads are master classes in working under considerable pressure and constraints. I’ve said before that I find short stories more challenging than novels because there’s so little room for error—you need to hit that target precisely, without the slightest deviation to either side. That’s all the more true of ads, which are operating within the smallest space imaginable: usually a single magazine page or commercial slot, which can be as short as fifteen seconds. Within that narrow window, an ad can create a character, present a story, tell a joke, or evoke an emotion, and although most of them are forgotten at once, a handful survive, to the point where some even outlast the original products themselves. And none of this is theoretical: a television commercial is thrown into a Darwinian world in which all elements of craft are intensely practical. Which isn’t to say that anyone in his or her right mind should actually go into advertising. But it’s also possible to look to the field itself as a source of insights and ideas while keeping a safe distance.

Bubble by Volkswagen

That said, advertisers and clients are only human, which is why most ads try for an easy way out. Humor, for instance, seems intuitively simple, even if it isn’t—hence the endless string of lavishly mounted but painfully unfunny ads that we see during every Super Bowl. (As Ogilvy writes: “I must warn you that very, very few writers can write funny commercials which are funny. Unless you are one of the few, don’t try.”) Super Bowl commercials are particularly handicapped by their simultaneous attempt to wow us and amuse us, a deadly combination for comedy; the result is usually shrill, desperate for laughs, and leaves viewers feeling as if they’ve been manhandled by an aggressive clown at a frat party. This isn’t to say that you can’t make a funny television commercial with big production values, but that when it fails, the result is awkward and a little pathetic. It’s probably better, if you don’t have any real ideas, to go for sex and bombast: I was recently startled to realize that it’s been fifteen years since the premiere of a certain Pepsi spot, and even more startled that I still remember the whole thing, even if it didn’t quite succeed in making me switch from Coke.

And the rarest achievement of all is for a commercial to evoke real, complicated emotion and nostalgia, which is why my own favorite Super Bowl ad might seem like a strange choice: Dodge Ram’s “Farmer,” built around Paul Harvey’s famous speech. It’s openly manipulative, yes, but brilliantly constructed, and the mild backlash that it provoked in some circles can only be taken as a testament to its power. It even got to me, and I’m not exactly in Dodge’s target demographic. (Oddly enough, my favorite commercial of all time, “Bubble” by Volkswagen, is also an ad for a car, although to the best of my knowledge it never aired during the Super Bowl.) If you want to be cynical about it, you can say that the Ram ad is a reminder to always steal from the best: it trades tremendously on Harvey’s original speech, in the same way lesser commercials lean on famous songs, and it’s essentially a more polished remake of an ad made two years earlier by It also suits its style to its subject in a way that doesn’t leave us feeling cheated when we find out what we’re really being sold, as De Niro and Scorsese did, alas, with American Express. Ultimately, as with all effective advertising, you can either love it or hate it. But you can’t ignore it.

Written by nevalalee

January 31, 2014 at 9:09 am

One Response

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Nice Information, thanks for sharing. Hope we will read many other good things from you in future also.


    February 23, 2014 at 7:25 am

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: